Review: ‘Great House’ by Nicole Krauss

Great House is not so much one novel but four: split between past and present, its five narrators each tell their story. Although the blurb states that it is ‘a desk of many drawers’ which connects these tales, the narrations are bound more tightly by questions of heredity, roots and loss.

The novel starts with Nadia, who for 25 years has written at the desk which was left in her flat by a young Chilean poet who disappeared into the hands of Pinochet’s secret police. Then there is Lotte Berg, a generation older but also a writer who worked at the desk for many years. Lotte’s story is told by her husband, who has found out his wife’s darkest secret only after her death, and is haunted by what the desk represents. The Weisz family feature too: George Weisz – the commanding father of Leah and Yoav – devotes his life to finding the desk, which belonged to his father. For Leah and Yoav, the desk represents their continual struggle with their father and his obsession with the past. Their tale is told by Isabelle; Yaov’s lover and outsider to the Weisz family.

The only story with no link to the desk is Aaron’s – the story of an old Israeli who, coming to the end of his life, has to face up to the void between him and one of his adult sons, who he has never been able to relate to. This, for me, is the most resonant story: Aaron’s resentment, anger and unexpressed love for his son make for a thrilling narration.

“We search for patterns, you see, only to find where the patterns break. And it’s there, in that fissure, that we pitch out tents and wait”

The novel can be confusing – the sudden changes of character and setting (the book straddles four cities: London, Oxford, New York and Jerusalem) do disrupt the flow of the book, and the links between the stories can seem tenuous. But the disjointed tales are all connected one way or another, and in the end the links are almost irrelevant: Krauss is challenging the reader to overcome the lack of structure, to step back and to see the big picture – the Great House.

Despite this, the beauty of the book is not in the larger picture but in the detail of the narrations: Krauss’s skill as a writer is undeniable. Her characters are made human by their pride, lack of faith and inability to identify with each other. The novel can be hard to piece together when you’re reading it (even after reading it I feel like it needs a second going through to identify all of the smaller links) but it is so rewarding to piece together. It is a novel I know I will not forget.

M.

To find out more about the Orange Prize, go to http://www.orangeprize.co.uk/ or check out their facebook page at http://www.facebook.com/orangeprize

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Books

The Orange Prize Youth Panel’s Verdict!

Following our judging meeting last week, the youth panel‘s decision was announced yesterday: our winner is Room by Emma Donoghue, although the real winner of the prize will be announced this evening.

To read more about the youth panel’s decision, visit the Orange Newsroom.

This is what I had to say about the novel and our decision as a panel:

“We all agreed Room stood out. For us, it was the most accessible and gripping, and a real page turner. It’s an horrific tale told with powerful innocence – we all felt it changes the way you view the world and makes you question your environment.”

To read my full review of Room, click here. I loved the novel, and it was clear from the start of the youth panel’s meeting that Room was the most popular.

M x.x

3 Comments

Filed under Books

The Orange Prize Youth Judging Panel

Yesterday was the Orange Prize youth judges’ meeting, so we met in central london to discuss the shortlist and pick our winner. It was so much fun meeting the other 5 youth judges and even though all the novels were amazing it was pretty clear which book had the most support from the start. I’m really pleased with the result, which will be announced next week…

Bring on the awards ceremony!

If you want to find out more about the Orange Prize, go to http://www.orangeprize.co.uk/ or check out their facebook page http://www.facebook.com/orangeprize

M x.x

1 Comment

Filed under Books

Review: ‘Grace Williams Says it Loud’ by Emma Henderson

A debut novel, Grace Williams Says it Loud is another novel on the Orange Prize shortlist. It tells Grace’s story – the story of a “spastic” and “mental defective” who is sent to a mental institute at the age of eleven. Set in the 1950s onwards, the novel explores the stigma attached to disability at the time, and now.

The novel focuses particularly on Grace’s relationship with Daniel, an epileptic who she meets at the Briar. They are both friends and lovers – Daniel is the one person who treats Grace with love and care. Essentially the novel is the story of Grace and Daniel’s love: love against the odds.

Grace narrates the story; her voice is poetic and assured but at the same time very detached and matter of fact. The removed tone Grace uses can seem at odds with the brutality of some of the scenes, sometimes detracting from the potency of some of the sadder and more shocking events. In places, the tone of the novel seems downright wrong: Grace reports violence and sexual abuse in a disconnected and even inappropriate way which makes it hard to be affected by her voice.  The novel can be jarring – the contrast between how the reader gets to know Grace (from inside her head) and how others view Grace is claustrophobic.

However, one incident in the book touched me deeply – when Grace is taken by her parents to visit the house of  a cellist in order to buy a cello for her younger sister. The man who sells them the instrument has a ‘different’ daughter, too, and although Grace’s parents fail to understand and appreciate their daughter, this man knows how to approach Grace. It was only here, when Grace was treated as a valued individual by someone other than Daniel, that I was struck by the tragedy of Grace’s situation.

Since I’ve finished the book, I’ve come to appreciate its beauty and pertinence. But I can’t help thinking that Emma Henderson’s attempt to voice the thoughts of a disabled person fails to bridge the gap between normality and disability: Grace remains distant and hard to relate to for most of the novel.

M.

If you want to find out more about the Orange Prize, go to http://www.orangeprize.co.uk/ or check out their facebook page http://www.facebook.com/orangeprize

Leave a comment

Filed under Books

Review: ‘Room’ by Emma Donoghue

As promised, here is a review of Room by Emma Donoghue- which is on the Orange Prize 2011 Shortlist:

Told through the eyes of five year old Jack, Room is inspired by cases such as those of Elizabeth Fritzl and Jaycee Lee Dugard. Trapped in a shed with only his Ma for company since the day of his birth, Jack has absolutely no concept of a world outside Room.

Naturally, the novel is grim and disturbing at times: every evening comes the inevitable time when ‘Old Nick’ enters Room through the locked door and gets into bed with Ma whilst Jack hides in the wardrobe and counts ‘till he makes that gaspy sound and stops’. But the sickening is constantly balanced with the uplifting and the author has managed to salvage something honest and beautiful from the most suffocating of circumstances.

What makes the novel so convincing is the relationship between mother and son. Jack’s love for Ma shines through his narrative, despite his gradual realisation that Ma is lying to him and that there is indeed a world outside Room.

Jack’s voice is unique: as a 5 year old his words, often half formed and inarticulate, are striking and often poetical, and his language does progress throughout the novel – his fluency improves with his growing understanding of the real world.

In the second half of the novel the setting shifts to outside Room, and Jack is overwhelmed with a world that is infinitely bigger than eleven square feet. With a realistic yet hopeful ending, Ma gradually learns to come to terms with her past in Room. Although it is clear that they have a long way to go, there is a sense of release and closure when they return to Room for one final goodbye before finally resuming – or beginning – their lives.

It’s hard not to be moved by Jack’s voice: told in his words, the disturbing story is honest and innocent, creating a novel that is darkly beautiful. I can truthfully say that I have never read a book like Room; it is a novel which leaves you with a lingering feeling that  something, somewhere within you, has changed.

M x.x

3 Comments

Filed under Books

Ivy – 90210

Despite the wealth of fashion-y fashion on 90210, it’s Ivy’s laid back style which y’all want to know about… well here you go:

Ivy’s casual surfer style sets her apart from the other girls in 90210: she’s not a skirt girl but still shows off her aaamazing legs in short shorts or skin tight jeans – which are usually ripped and/or frayed. She usually goes for more loose fitting or oversized tops but layers lots of bracelets, necklaces, and or rings and occasionally a little hat too.

Her sun bleached blonde hair is one of my eternal envies, it’s just so long and free-flowing and ahhhh…

M x.x

Leave a comment

Filed under Fashion, T.V.

Review: ‘Annabel’ by Kathleen Winter

As it is on the Orange Prize shortlist 2011, Annabel was another novel I had to read as part of my role as an Orange Prize youth judge. It is the powerful story of a hermaphrodite born in 1968 into the remote north-east coast of Canada. Although the baby’s parents decide to go through surgery and raise the child as a boy named Wayne, as Wayne grows up his stifled shadow-self – a girl he thinks of as Annabel – begins to cry out.

Kathleen Winter captures the loneliness of the stark environment beautifully – a loneliness which is mirrored in Wayne, who must navigate the difficulty of hiding the woman inside him. Although Wayne has some support, nobody really understands him.

In an attempt to label him, to slot him into society’s rigid norms, a whole half of who Wayne is is suppressed. The compassionate novel raises issues concerning not only gender, but of individuality and belonging: Winter questions our perception of what ‘normal’ is, and the effects of our categorical culture.

The novel is beautifully written: understated but all the more moving because of that. Winter does not indulge the characters with sympathy but tells their story in a delicate manner which allows the reader to understand their situation all the better.

M x.x

If you want to find out more about the Orange Prize, go to http://www.orangeprize.co.uk/ or go to their facebook page http://www.facebook.com/orangeprize

1 Comment

Filed under Books